Two businesses can generate the same earnings and still end up with different tax outcomes. The difference often comes down to structure and how taxable income is defined. The Qualified Business Income (QBI) deduction could reduce taxable income for many pass-through owners. But the benefit is not uniform, and the result can shift based on business type, wages, and how income is categorized.
Sole proprietors and S-Corp owners may see different outcomes even at the same earnings level. This is not about finding a universal “better” choice; it is about understanding which path could help keep more of what the business makes, based on each situation.
This article will explain everything you need to know and is meant to be informational, but not tax or legal advice.
📌 Also read: Top 20 Tax Deductions Every Freelancer Should Know for 2026 Taxes
What the QBI Deduction Means in 2026
The Qualified Business Income (QBI) deduction is a potential reduction in taxable income for many pass-through business owners. It does not apply the same way to every business, and the final figure often depends on income type, total taxable income, and business category.
In general, QBI can apply to income reported from a sole proprietorship, partnership or multi-member LLC, S-Corp, and some trust or estate income. It also has a separate component for qualified REIT dividends and certain publicly traded partnership income.
If eligible, the deduction could reach up to 20% of qualified business income, but this is not a flat 20% for everyone. The calculation can shift based on income limits, business type, and wage and property factors. Form 8995 and Form 8995-A are the IRS forms used to calculate the deduction. The shorter form applies to simpler cases. The longer form includes wage, property, and phase-out tests.
📝 Note: The deduction reduces taxable income, not self-employment tax, payroll tax, or Medicare tax.
Understanding Business Category and Income Limits
Some businesses fall into a group the IRS calls a Specified Service Trade or Business (SSTB). This includes fields like health services, law, consulting, and similar professional services where income is tied to reputation, knowledge, or skill.
Other businesses fall into the non-SSTB category, which may include product sellers, manufacturers, real estate operators, photographers, and many trades where income is not primarily based on personal services.
The distinction matters because SSTBs face a faster reduction of the deduction as taxable income rises. Non-SSTBs do not lose the deduction the same way, but they can hit wage and property limitations at higher incomes.
✅ SSTB (examples, not a full list)
Health services, law, consulting, financial services, accounting, performing arts, athletics
✅ Non-SSTB (examples, not a full list)
Many retail businesses, real estate rentals, manufacturing, construction, e-commerce, repair services
❌ Common misconception: All pass-through businesses get the full 20% deduction.
In reality, the deduction can shrink, phase out, or hit formula limits, depending on income level and business type.
Wage and Property Limits at Higher Incomes
The QBI deduction may also be limited by a wage and property test once taxable income is above the annual thresholds.
When this limit applies, the IRS caps the deduction at the greater of:
- 50% of total W-2 wages paid by the business, or
- 25% of W-2 wages + 2.5% of the cost basis (UBIA) of qualified property
UBIA refers to the original cost of long-term, depreciable property the business owns, as long as it is still in its allowed depreciable period.
✏️ Hypothetical Example:
A business pays $120,000 in W-2 wages and owns qualifying equipment with a cost basis of $300,000. The wage limit tests would be:
- 50% ✕ $120,000 = $60,000
- 25% ✕ $120,000 + 2.5% ✕ $300,000 = $30,000 + $7,500 = $37,500
In this case, $60,000 is the higher limit used in the formula.
Key points to remember:
✅ Wage limits do not apply to every filer, only at higher taxable incomes
✅ Having employees or qualifying property matters more as income rises
✅ SSTBs may lose the deduction faster than non-SSTBs
How QBI Works for S-Corps and Sole Proprietors
Business structure affects how income flows into the QBI formula. Two companies can report the same earnings and still end up with different deduction results. The difference is not about better or worse. It is tied to how income is categorized, what counts as wages, and what does not.
S-Corps split owner income into W-2 wages and pass-through profit. Sole proprietors report business profit as a single stream of income. Each path interacts with QBI rules in different ways, especially at higher income levels where wage and property limits may apply.
📝 Note: QBI applies to qualified business income. It does not apply to wages, guaranteed payments, or investment income.
Owner Pay Rules That Shape the QBI Math
S-Corp owners take a reasonable salary for work performed in the business. The IRS requires this wage to be paid through payroll. It is reported as W-2 income. That wage does not count as QBI, but it can help satisfy the wage portion of the deduction limit at higher income levels.
Sole proprietors do not pay themselves wages. Business profit becomes the starting point for QBI. That full profit number may look higher, but there is no owner wage to support the wage-based limit if it applies. Only wages paid to actual employees count toward that test.
S-Corp owner income
✅ Must include reasonable W-2 wages
✅ Wages do not count as QBI
✅ Wages can support the wage limit if the limit applies
✅ Remaining profit could qualify as QBI
Sole proprietor income
✅ No W-2 wages for the owner
✅ Business profit can be QBI
✅ No owner wage to support wage limit at higher incomes
✅ Only employee wages count if wage limits apply
A Simple Same Earnings Comparison
✏️ Hypothetical Example:
Two business owners each generate $100,000 in earnings before owner pay.
S-Corp
- Owner takes $40,000 W-2 salary
- The W-2 salary is not QBI
- Remaining $60,000 may count as QBI
- The $40,000 in W-2 wages may help support the wage limit, if triggered
Sole Proprietor
- No W-2 salary for the owner
- The full $100,000 may count as QBI
- No owner wages exist to support a wage limit
- If wage limits apply, only employee payroll counts, if any
📝 Note: More QBI income on paper does not always mean a larger deduction in practice. Wage support can matter more at higher incomes, especially for businesses without employees.
Key Decision Factors for S-Corp vs Sole Proprietor
Use this quick checklist to judge which structure might suit QBI planning. Anchor decisions to the current IRS forms and instructions (Form 8995 or Form 8995-A) when you model outcomes. For deeper how-to guidance on payroll, compensation policy, and entity maintenance, see the S-Corp cluster in this guide.
Income Level and Thresholds
How much taxable income you report before the QBI deduction is central. Below the lower threshold, the simplified computation usually applies and many filers avoid wage/UBIA limits. Once taxable income moves into and above the phase-in range, the deduction is trimmed by SSTB rules and by the wage/property formula.
For 2026, the IRS uses $203,000 for single filers and $406,000 for married filing jointly as the lower threshold; the phase-in range is $75,000 ($150,000 MFJ). Above the top of the range, SSTBs generally lose the deduction and the full wage/property limitation applies.
Quick check:
- Taxable income under the lower threshold → simplified Form 8995 path is likely.
- Taxable income inside or above the phase-in range → model wage/UBIA impact on Form 8995-A.
Administrative Costs and Compliance
Electing S-corp status typically adds payroll, reasonable-compensation documentation, and corporate filings. Those costs reduce the net benefit of any tax savings. Run a simple cost/benefit model: estimate annual payroll and TPA/accounting fees, compare those to projected QBI and self-employment tax differences, and anchor the math to the current IRS worksheet for Form 8995-A.
Quick check:
- Small projected tax gains vs meaningful payroll and compliance costs → sole proprietor often remains simpler.
- Projected gains that exceed admin costs and compliance risk → S-corp may be worth modeling.
State Tax Treatment and Law Risk
State tax rules vary. Some states do not follow federal QBI rules, so a federal QBI benefit may not reduce state taxable income. California, for example, historically decoupled from the federal QBI deduction. Check your state’s conformity status before relying on federal-only savings. Also monitor federal law changes that affect QBI timing or permanence and adjust models accordingly.
Quick check:
- If your state does not conform to federal QBI → model federal and state returns separately.
Practical Modeling Checklist
✅ Use the current year’s IRS forms and instructions (Form 8995 or Form 8995-A).
✅ Start with taxable income before the QBI deduction.
✅ For S-corps, include a reasonable-compensation estimate and payroll costs.
✅ For sole proprietors, include projected self-employment tax and the absence of owner wages.
✅ Run scenarios: under threshold, inside phase-in, and above phase-in.
✅ Check state conformity and any pending federal changes before finalizing a decision
📝 Note: If a single factor is driving the choice (e.g., a small number of W-2 wages or a non-conforming state), pause and model the full combined effect. A higher QBI number on paper does not always produce a larger deduction in practice.
Final Thoughts
There is no single winner when comparing S-Corp vs Sole Proprietor for QBI. QBI outcomes may change based on taxable income, business type, and how owner income is paid.
Run both setups using the current IRS forms. Some filers may use Form 8995; others may need Form 8995-A if wage or property limits apply. A quick comparison can reveal how wages and income thresholds influence the deduction.
A sole proprietorship may involve less administrative work. An S-Corp may add payroll and filings, but owner wages could support the deduction at higher incomes. Re-check the math each year, since thresholds, forms, and state rules can change.
A small amount of planning and a yearly review can make the choice clearer over time.
Disclaimer:
The Carry Learning Center is operated by The Vibes Company Inc. (“Vibes”) and contains generalized educational content about personal finance topics. While Vibes provides educational content and technology services, all investment advisory services discussed on this website are provided exclusively through its wholly-owned subsidiary, Carry Advisors LLC (“Carry Advisors”), an SEC registered investment adviser. The information contained on the Carry Learning Center should not be construed as personalized investment advice and should not be considered as a solicitation to buy or sell any security or engage in a particular investment, accounting, tax or legal strategy. Vibes is not providing tax, legal, accounting, or investment advice. You should consult with qualified tax, legal, accounting, and investment professionals regarding your specific situation.
The accounts, strategies and/or investments discussed in this material may not be suitable for all investors. All investments involve the risk of loss, and past performance does not guarantee future results. Investment growth or profit is never a guarantee. All statements and opinions included on the Carry Learning Center are intended to be current as of the date of publication but are subject to change without notice.
To access investment advisory services through Carry Advisors, you must be a client of Vibes on an eligible membership plan. For more information about Carry Advisors’ investment advisory services, please see our Form ADV Part 2A brochure and Form CRS or through the SEC’s website at www.adviserinfo.sec.gov.