OVERVIEW

Key Similarities

  • Eligible rollovers are reported on IRS Forms 1099-R and 5498 (except trustee-to-trustee IRA transfers).
  • Both direct and indirect rollovers can move unlimited amounts between retirement accounts.
  • Neither type is taxable if done correctly. Indirect rollovers require redepositing the full amount within 60 days to avoid taxes and possible 10% penalties if under age 59½.

Key Differences

  • Direct rollovers move funds directly between trustees. Indirect rollovers send funds to you first, and you must deposit them into the new account.
  • Direct rollovers have no limit on frequency. The once-per-year rule applies only to IRA-to-IRA 60-day rollovers, not IRA-to-employer plan rollovers.
  • Direct rollovers avoid mandatory withholding. Indirect rollovers from employer plans withhold 20% by default; IRA distributions default to 10% but can be adjusted, even to 0%.

Moving retirement funds from one account to another can be a pivotal step in managing long-term savings. Whether shifting money from a 401k to an IRA or moving between other retirement plans, understanding how rollovers work can help avoid unnecessary taxes and penalties.

There are two primary types of rollovers: direct and indirect. Each has its own rules for handling funds, reporting to the IRS, and potential withholding. Knowing how they differ can guide you toward an option that fits your financial situation without risking mistakes.

📌 Also read: Can You Lose Money in a Roth IRA? Mistakes To Avoid

Table of contents

Direct vs Indirect Rollovers: What’s the Difference?

✅ Direct rollover — This moves funds straight from one retirement plan or custodian to another. The money typically never reaches you. It’s often transferred electronically or by a check payable to the new trustee “for the benefit of” (FBO) you.

✅ Indirect rollover — Often called a 60-day rollover, an indirect rollover works differently. The check is issued to you, and you’re responsible for redepositing the full gross amount into the new plan or IRA within 60 days. Missing that window can trigger taxes and, if you’re under age 59½, an additional 10% penalty.

Payers issue Form 1099-R for reportable rollovers such as employer-plan direct rollovers and indirect rollovers. Trustee-to-trustee IRA transfers generally aren’t reported on Form 1099-R. Both direct and indirect rollovers are non-taxable when handled properly, but indirect rollovers require careful timing and full redeposit of the gross amount to avoid taxes.

📝 Note: For indirect rollovers, redepositing the entire gross amount, including any tax withheld, is essential to keep the transaction non-taxable.

Similarities Between Direct and Indirect Rollovers

Payers issue Form 1099-R for reportable rollovers such as employer-plan direct rollovers and indirect rollovers. Trustee-to-trustee IRA transfers generally are not reported on Form 1099-R.

Both direct and indirect rollovers are non-taxable when handled properly. However, indirect rollovers require redepositing the full gross amount within 60 days to avoid taxes and, if you’re under age 59½, a possible 10% additional tax.

📝 Note: The 60-day redeposit rule for indirect rollovers includes any amounts withheld for taxes.

How Direct Rollovers Work

A direct rollover moves funds straight from your old plan’s trustee to your new plan’s trustee. You, as the account holder, never handle the money. This process helps maintain tax-deferred status and minimizes the chance of accidental penalties.

Direct rollovers are often called trustee-to-trustee transfers when funds move directly. However, “transfers” such as IRA-to-IRA movements are not considered rollovers and are generally not reported on Form 1099-R.

📌 Also read: What Is A Retirement Plan? (Different Plan Types Explained)

How Indirect Rollovers Work

An indirect rollover occurs when your old plan’s trustee sends the money to you instead of directly to your new trustee. You’re then responsible for depositing the entire gross amount into your new retirement account within 60 days to keep the rollover non-taxable. 

  • If you miss the deadline or deposit less than the gross amount, the distribution becomes taxable and may incur a 10% penalty if under age 59½ (unless an exception applies).
  • The 60-day clock starts the day after you receive the funds from your old plan provider, not the day you initiate the transfer.

Because of this time limit, indirect rollovers are often called 60-day rollovers. 

Withholding Rules

  • Employer plans such as 401k accounts must withhold 20% for federal taxes if funds are paid to you.
  • IRA distributions have a default withholding of 10% on non-periodic payments. You can elect a different rate, including 0%, by filing the proper election.

Why It Gets Tricky

The withheld amount is deducted from the check you receive, yet you’re still required to redeposit the full gross balance into your new account. This means you may need to use other funds to make up the difference and complete the rollover. 

The withheld amount counts as federal income tax withheld for the year of distribution and appears as a credit on your tax return. If you successfully redeposit the full gross amount within 60 days, the rollover remains non-taxable and any excess withholding may be refunded.

✏️ Hypothetical Example:

You have $100,000 in your 401k and initiate an indirect rollover. You receive $80,000 after the mandatory 20% withholding. To complete the rollover, you must deposit $100,000 into your new account within 60 days — topping up $20,000 from other funds. The rollover remains non-taxable, and the $20,000 withheld is credited on your tax return for the distribution year.

📝 Note: Always track the 60-day deadline carefully. The countdown starts the day after you receive the funds, not the day you initiate the transfer.

Why Some People Choose an Indirect Rollover

Direct rollovers are generally simpler. Funds move straight to the new plan provider with nothing withheld, so you avoid handling the deposit yourself and reduce the chance of penalties. This makes them the preferred choice for many account holders.

Still, some people choose an indirect rollover because it allows temporary access to funds during the 60-day window. This flexibility can be appealing, but it comes with strict rules and real risks.

Reasons People Consider Indirect Rollovers

✅ Temporary access to funds within the 60-day period
✅ Flexibility to use the money before redepositing it
✅ No IRS restrictions on how the funds are used during that period

Some Risks to Keep in Mind

❌ Mandatory withholding (20% for employer plans, 10% default for IRAs unless changed)
❌ Strict 60-day redeposit requirement to keep it non-taxable
❌ Possible taxes and an additional 10% penalty if under age 59½ when rules aren’t met

📝 Note: Indirect rollovers may only make sense if you are certain you can replace the withheld amount from other funds and redeposit the entire gross balance within 60 days. Otherwise, a direct rollover is typically less risky.

In Summary

Direct and indirect rollovers both move retirement funds from one account to another, but they work differently. Direct rollovers transfer money straight between trustees, avoiding withholding and reducing the chance of mistakes.

Indirect rollovers send funds to you first and require redepositing the full gross amount within 60 days to remain non-taxable. This approach may offer temporary access to funds but comes with stricter rules and greater risk.

It’s helpful to review your ability to meet the 60-day requirement and replace withheld amounts before choosing an indirect rollover. Many account holders find direct rollovers simpler and less risky.


Disclaimer:

The Carry Learning Center is operated by The Vibes Company Inc. (“Vibes”) and contains generalized educational content about personal finance topics. While Vibes provides educational content and technology services, all investment advisory services discussed on this website are provided exclusively through its wholly-owned subsidiary, Carry Advisors LLC (“Carry Advisors”), an SEC registered investment adviser. The information contained on the Carry Learning Center should not be construed as personalized investment advice and should not be considered as a solicitation to buy or sell any security or engage in a particular investment, accounting, tax or legal strategy. Vibes is not providing tax, legal, accounting, or investment advice. You should consult with qualified tax, legal, accounting, and investment professionals regarding your specific situation.

The accounts, strategies and/or investments discussed in this material may not be suitable for all investors. All investments involve the risk of loss, and past performance does not guarantee future results. Investment growth or profit is never a guarantee. All statements and opinions included on the Carry Learning Center are intended to be current as of the date of publication but are subject to change without notice.

To access investment advisory services through Carry Advisors, you must be a client of Vibes on an eligible membership plan. For more information about Carry Advisors’ investment advisory services, please see our Form ADV Part 2A brochure and Form CRS or through the SEC’s website at www.adviserinfo.sec.gov.